Unlike the history of haggis, which took some digging, it appears that there is lots of evidence for German bratwurst, and many opinions about who has the oldest evidence. Therefore, I am mostly going to piece together existing sources for this one, but starting with a picture from http://medievalcookery.blogspot.ca/2010/01/medieval-hot-dog-stand.html
La grigliata – The Grill
17th century German etching
Livio e Wilma Cerini di Castegnate Collection
On the website it’s described as “A rare representation of a women selling grilled vegetables outdoors.” A nice, simple picture. No surprises in terms of cooking utensils or methods. No big deal. I’m about to go on to the next image when I take a closer look at what’s in the customer’s hands. For all the world, it looks like a sausage in a bun. Maybe it’s just being served with a piece of bread? No, it definitely looks like the bread is cut down the middle, with the sausage between the halves.
Now the common belief is that sausage sellers first started putting sausages into split rolls sometime in the late 19th century, so I doubt my own eyes and post a link on a cooking mailing list. The quick consensus is that it does indeed look like a sausage in a bun. Then someone suggests that the caption on the etching might shed some light on things. My German is only good enough to know that it says something about “good fried sausages”, but a better translation is provided moments later. “Here, a decent sausage is roasted for not much money, with which hunger can be appeased but not thirst. This (thirst) can be appeased later as much as someone wants in a place where wine and beer is sold”. [translation courtesy of Emilio Szabo, via the SCA-Cooks mailing list]
A postmedieval document in Nürnberg with the recipe for Bratwurst is dated 1595 and was long believed to be the oldest recipe. But in 2000 an archivist, Peter Unger, found a bill for sausage skins to be delivered to the monastery of the maidens in Arnstadt dating to 1404.(2) So the Thüringer Rostbratwurst celebrated its 600th birthday in 2004. A legend says, that in the 7th century sorbish settlers entered Thüringen and caused the inhabitants to flee. On the road one of the refugees is said to have invented the Bratwurst.(3) The problem is, that nether the bill nor the legend give any clue to the recipe. The historian Michael Kirschlager claims to have found the oldest recipe in Thüringen. Much older are the records for stalls selling Bratwürste. In 1134 a kiosk is reported in Regensburg, selling Bratwurst to the construction workers of the cathedral and of the “Steinerne Brücke” (stone bridge). In 1146 the “Wurstkuchl” (sausage kitchen) was build near the salt house directly to the city wall.(4) In the 14th century the “Bratwurstglöcklein” (Glöcklein = little bell; named after a bell hanging from the wall of the chapel) was built in Nürnberg directly to the walls of the Moritz chapel. From the beginning it was quite famous and many people, including many celebrities, ate there. Its tradition lasted till the 20th century, when it was destroyed in WW II by bombs. But the original recipe of the “Glöcklein-Bratwurst” is still used in Nürnberg.(5)
There were and are still many different recipes for Bratwurst used in Germany, depending on the region or town you are in.
Čerpnjak Dorothea: Kleine Kulturgeschichte der Bratwurst. Eine Lieblingsspeise erobert die Welt. Leipzig 2005. (Cultural History of the Bratwurst. A favoured Dish conquers the World)
Dünnebier, Anna/ Paczensky, Gert von: Kulturgeschichte des Essens und Trinkens. München 1999. (Culutral History of Food and Drink)
1 Čerpnjak, p. 8-12; Dünnebier, p. 53, 54, 55
2 Čerpnjak, p. 28
3 Čerpnjak, p. 29
4 Čerpnjak, p. 30-31; Dünnebier, p. 126
5 Čerpnjak, p. 30-31
From the Bratwurst Museum in Thuringia, (http://www.bratwurstmuseum.de/geschichte.html) there is a similar timeline:
- 1134 Builders of the Regensburg Cathedral strengthen in close proximity in a snack hut (possibly with bratwurst )
- 1404 – Entry for the issue of 1 penny for intestines make to sausages in the provost’s account of the Arnstadt Virgin Monastery
- Early 14th century . Nuremberg Bratwurstglöcklein built on the outer wall of the Santander Moritzkapelle
- 1432 Fleischhauer order of the Weimar Fleischer ” something of a purity law for the roasting , liver and other sausages “
- 1470 (1370) in Esslingen dictates an order that only pure pork may be used for the production of sausages
- 1498 Coburg bratwurst is first mentioned in a bill of fare of George ‘s Hospital
- 1554 – . 1592 Hans Stromer IV ( 1517-1592 ) eats behind bars in Nuremberg debtors’ prison , nearly 28,000 sausages
- 1595 bratwurst recipe of the Nuremberg butchers’ guild
- 1600/1601 Konigsberg giant sausage measuring 1,005 yards ( 670 m)
- 02/07/1613 “S ( axes ) W ( eimarischen ) Product and order for butchers to Weimar , Jena and Buttstaedt ,” § 25 Bratwurst
- 1669 Johann Jacob Christoffel of Grimmelshausen praises the “adventurous Simplicius Simplicissimus” Thuringian bratwurst
- 1797 First printed recipe for Thuringian sausages in the ” Thuringian- Erfurtisches Cookbook
The discovery of the 1404 document sparked a debate about whose documentation for bratwurst was the oldest: (http://www.graf-von-katzenelnbogen.de/bratwurst.html)
In the financial statements of the Customs writer of St. Goar dating back to 1410 is a boatload of sausages mentioned (Value: 1 Gulden), which was shipped together with wine in Cologne. This is the clearest and earliest evidence for sausage, except for a document just six years older from Thuringia – the purchase of intestines to make sausages. This documents led to a bit of a dispute between Thuringians and Franks out (http://www.tagesspiegel.de/weltspiegel/geschichte-der-bratwurst-neue-historische-quelle-ruft-streit-zwischen-thueringern-und-franken-hervor/153812.htm) in July 2000:
The history of the sausage must probably be rewritten because the crispy grilled food is obviously older than thought. The sausage was mentioned in 1404 in Thuringia for the first time in a document, writes the “Thüringer Allgemeine” in its weekend edition. Previously, the oldest documents to mention sausage were from 1595 and 1613, attributed to the citizens of Nuremberg.
There is now a raging controversy between Thuringia and Franconia over the oldest sausage. “The Nuremberg Bratwurst has certainly been mentioned in 1300,” fought back the chairman of the Hotel and Restaurant Association for Middle Franconia, Werner Behringer, against this new disgrace. By 1313 in Nuremberg there was evidence of bratwurst in the mention of the bratwurst kitchen “to blue bell” near the Sebald Church, stressed Behringer. The oldest sausage kitchen in the world was definitely in Bavaria.
The 1432 document that was recently discovered has also sparked a debate, but this time it was over who had the oldest purity laws: butchers or brewers. Craig Whitlock wrote in the Washington post in December 2007 about this:
“It’s the German version of the chicken-or-the-egg conundrum: Which was regulated first, beer or bratwurst?
For centuries, brewers seemed to have history on their side. As evidence, they cited the world-renowned Reinheitsgebot, the Bavarian beer purity law of 1516, which stipulated barley, hops and water as the only permissible ingredients in the German national drink.
But thanks to Hubert Erzmann, a 75-year-old amateur historian, sausage lovers are crowing these days. Digging in the Weimar city archives, Erzmann unearthed a yellowed, handwritten parchment from 1432 that laid down the law regarding the production of Thuringian Rostbratwurst, perhaps the most popular variety of sausage in a country where wurst is worshiped as sacred grub.
The official document decreed that bratwurst from this corner of Thuringia, today a central German state, be made only from “pure, fresh” pork. Forbidden were beef, internal organs, parasites and anything rancid.
Although the regulations might not sound revolutionary, wurst aficionados have described the bratwurst purity law as a holy find, almost as significant to German culture as a Gutenberg Bible.
“As soon as I found it, I ran to the director of the archive and said, ‘Look! Look what I found!’ ” recalled Erzmann, who has haunted the archives for years in hopes of making such a discovery.
Food purity laws hold a revered place in the German soul. When the modern German nation was formed in 1871, Bavaria joined on condition that its beer purity rules be applied to the entire country. Even today, spoiled meat outbreaks are a national scandal and consumer protection is considered among the most important functions of government.
“The medieval regulations in Germany were incredibly modern,” said Michael Kirchschlager, an author who writes about Thuringian culture. “When you think of the Middle Ages, you think the food wasn’t necessarily that safe. But the hygiene in many ways was better than today.”
A replica of the bratwurst purity law soon will be enshrined at the German Bratwurst Museum ( http://www.bratwurstmuseum.net), located 24 miles away in Holzhausen, a village whose main intersection is marked by a giant sausage-and-bun sculpture.”
In an article found at
http://www.kitchenproject.com/german/Bratwurst/history.htm, we learn that Thuringian sausage makers had to use only the purest, unspoiled meat and were threatened with a fine of 24 pfennigs — a day’s wages — if they did not, according to a spokesman for the German Bratwurst Museum said Wednesday.
Read Full Post »